This hub defines the [conviction construct] (Narrative_ConvictionFramework) as a measure of epistemic settledness, structured across a spectrum from ephemeral notions to foundational graves. The primary trajectory, formalized in April 2026, centers on the [orthogonality of conviction and temporality] (Narrative_ConvictionVsTemporality), a distinction necessitated by [pipeline conflation] (Position_ConvictionAndTemporalityAreDistinctAxes) that previously caused speculative future-state claims to be misread as current reality. [Scarlet’s canonical framing] (Obs_ConvictionTemporalityQuote) anchors this, asserting that high-conviction claims can exist for speculative or future-oriented states. This separation has received [technical validation] (Obs_DavidConvictionQuote) from early adopters, reinforcing the need to treat conviction independently of [review evidence] (Position_5), which tracks the validation thoroughness of the extraction process. Emerging alongside this is a [spaced-repetition model] (Narrative_ConvictionDecay) for conviction decay, proposing that unreinforced claims should lose weight over time, a [feature request] (Position_ConvictionDecayFeatureRequest) currently under consideration. Stylistically, the system employs [all-caps markers] (StyleObs_ConvictionLabel) like BOULDER to signal validated confidence within the graph.
verbatim Conviction is something that is supposed to be built over time, i.e., do people act? Do multiple people actually agree on it? I can be very sure about something that might need to happen in the future.
verbatim Conviction (how settled) and temporality (when it applies) are orthogonal axes that the extraction pipeline currently conflates
verbatim Conviction = epistemological settledness of knowledge itself; review evidence = thoroughness of extraction validation.
verbatim BOULDER used as an inline conviction label in all-caps
verbatim The proposal for conviction decay introduces a temporal dependency that challenges the static nature of the current conviction framework.
In this area
NarrativeNarrative_ConvictionDecay Conviction should decay over time when claims are not reinforced
NarrativeNarrative_ConvictionFramework Conviction Levels as Organizational Memory
Narrative_ConvictionVsTemporality Conviction ≠ Temporality: Two Distinct Axes in the Extraction Pipeline
ObservationObs_ConvictionDecayQuestion a founder beta user's spaced-repetition framing for conviction decay — a feature request for temporal graph analysis.
ObservationObs_ConvictionTemporalityQuote Scarlet's canonical statement distinguishing conviction from temporality as orthogonal axes.
ObservationObs_DavidConvictionQuote David Nolen asked for conviction unprompted — the founding evidence that the conviction/temporality distinction resonates with technical users.
StyleObservationStyleObs_ConvictionLabel BOULDER used as an inline conviction label in all-caps — a proprietary epistemic marker functioning as both metadata and rhetorical signal of validated confidence.
3 further nodes are not published in the public projection. Each node links from the entity index.